Why Smart People Are Terrible at Time Estimation
How to Estimate Project Time Without Losing Your Mind
Do you ever get that sinking feeling when someone asks, "How long will this take?" Your brain immediately starts doing mental gymnastics, calculating best-case scenarios while conveniently forgetting that you're human and stuff always goes sideways.
We've all been there. That moment where you confidently say "5 hours" and then watch in horror as it stretches into 20. Or when you pad your estimate, feel guilty about it, and then somehow still end up behind schedule anyway.
Let's be real: estimation sucks. It's not fun, it's often just educated guesswork, and everyone's breathing down your neck wanting guarantees you can't give. But here's the thing, it's also one of the most important skills you can develop, both for your sanity and your career.
Why We're Terrible at This (And Why It Matters)
Here's what nobody tells you about estimation: it's both a technical skill and a moral challenge. Yeah, I said moral.
Stay with me here.
The Stoics had this idea about speaking truthfully even when people prefer comfortable lies. That's exactly what happens with estimation. Clients want to hear "2 weeks," stakeholders want to hear "no problem," and your brain wants to believe you can somehow bend the laws of time and physics.
But here's the reality check: people need estimates because they want to know how much things will cost. Your job isn't to make people happy, it's to be as accurate as humanly possible so they can make informed decisions.
I once estimated 5 hours for what seemed like a simple feature update. "Just adding a button," I thought. Turns out it required touching legacy code that hadn't been modified in 3 years, integrating with a third-party API that wasn't documented properly, and oh yeah – the database schema was completely different than what I expected. 20 hours later, I learned why padding estimates isn't just smart, it's survival.
The Mental Traps That Screw Us Over
The "Perfect World" Fantasy
We estimate like we live in a bubble where nothing ever goes wrong. No meetings, no interruptions, no mysterious bugs that eat entire afternoons. We calculate pure coding time and forget we're human beings who need bathroom breaks and coffee.
The People-Pleasing Problem
Someone throws a deadline at you and you think, "Well, I could try to hit that date..." Stop. Just stop. Do you want the system to work or do you want it half-assed? Because those are your only two options when you accept impossible timelines.
The "I'll Figure It Out" Trap
"I don't really know how to implement this, but I'll figure it out as I go." Famous last words. Uncertainty isn't failure – it's information. Use it.
Strategies That Actually Work
Break It Down Like Your Life Depends on It
Don't estimate "build user authentication." Estimate:
Research current auth libraries (2-3 hours)
Set up basic login/logout (4-6 hours)
Add password reset functionality (3-5 hours)
Write tests (2-4 hours)
Handle edge cases you haven't thought of yet (4-8 hours)
See how quickly that "simple" auth system becomes a 15-25 hour project?
Separate Effort from Calendar Time
You might need 10 hours of focused coding time, but spread that across meetings, code reviews, Slack conversations, and the inevitable "can you just quickly look at this other thing?" interruptions. That 10 hours of work? It's probably taking 2-3 calendar days, minimum.
Give Ranges, Not False Precision
Stop saying "14.5 hours." Say "15-20 hours" and explain your reasoning. "This could be on the lower end if the API integration goes smoothly, but could hit the higher end if we need to refactor the existing payment code."
Track Your Actual vs. Estimated Time
This one's painful but necessary. Keep a simple log of what you estimated versus what actually happened. You'll start seeing patterns in where you consistently under or overestimate.
Account for the Invisible Work
Requirements that seemed clear but aren't
Code review feedback and iterations
Testing and bug fixes
Deployment and monitoring
Documentation (please don't skip this)
The random production fire you'll need to put out mid-project
Advocate for Sustainable Pace
Rushing creates technical debt. Technical debt creates future delays. Future delays create more rushing. It's a death spiral. Break the cycle by being honest about what "fast" actually costs.
How to Communicate Estimates Without Getting Fired
Be Upfront About Uncertainty
"I can give you a rough estimate, but there are a few unknowns that could significantly impact this." Then list them. Uncertainty isn't weakness, it's honesty.
Explain Your Assumptions
"This estimate assumes the current API documentation is accurate, that we won't need to modify the database schema, and that the existing user interface can accommodate these changes without major redesign."
Offer Phased Approaches
"We could build this in phases. Phase 1 gets you the core functionality in 2-3 weeks. Phase 2 adds the advanced features and might take another 3-4 weeks, depending on how Phase 1 goes and what we learn."
Accept That Some People Won't Like Reality
Some stakeholders will push back on realistic estimates. That's their problem, not yours. Your job is accuracy, not making people feel good about impossible timelines.
When Everything Goes Sideways (Because It Will)
Remember: if you find yourself falling behind, communicate early. Don't wait until the deadline to mention that you've hit unexpected complexity. The earlier you speak up, the more options everyone has.
And sometimes? Sometimes you just don't know. It's okay to say "This could take anywhere from 10 to 40 hours depending on what we find when we dig in. I can give you a better estimate after a few hours of investigation."
Your Estimation Action Plan
Ready to stop the estimation madness? Here's what you can start doing tomorrow:
Start tracking: Keep a simple log of estimated vs. actual time for the next month
Break everything down: Never estimate anything bigger than a day's worth of work
Add buffer time: Whatever you think it'll take, add 25-50% for the unexpected
Separate effort from calendar time: Account for all the non-coding activities
Communicate uncertainty: Give ranges and explain your assumptions
Look, estimation will probably always suck a little bit. But it doesn't have to be a source of constant stress and surprise. The goal isn't perfection, it's getting better at predicting reality so everyone can make smarter decisions.
Your projects are a journey, not a sprint to an arbitrary deadline. Yes, you'll face pressure to commit to impossible timelines. You'll have days when you want to just say "sure, whatever" and deal with the consequences later.
But here's the thing: the person who can make you a better estimator is the same person who's been winging it all along : you. Start tracking, start communicating, and start treating estimation like the skill it actually is.
Because at the end of the day, being known as someone who gives realistic estimates and hits them is way better than being known as someone who promises the moon and delivers chaos.
Quote of the Day:
"No great thing is created suddenly." - Epictetus
👉 If you enjoy reading this post, feel free to share it with friends!
Or feel free to click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Substack 🙏
You can find me on X and Instagram. Also, I just launched in new YouTube channel - Code & Composure